By Zara Jennings
Period piece adaptations are beloved for a reason– whether it is to absorb the atmosphere of a 19th century ball, or bask in the glory of a daring sword fight– these stories shape our perception of literature and perhaps our love for it. From Jane Austen to Louisa May Alcott, we have been well acquainted with characters like Mr. Darcy and Jo March. We empathize with their struggles, adore their literary existence, and learn about society in different centuries.
Below is a ranking of five film adaptations of classic novels worth the watch– five masterfully created pieces that will fill any audience with unforgettable adoration. And if people can fall in love with these movies, they can hopefully be perpetuated to reach for the novel.
1. PRIDE AND PREJUDICE (2005)
Joe Wright’s Pride and Prejudice is one of the most well known adaptations of all time, and a comfort film for many. The movie captures the novel’s true essence through cinematography, writing, and acting, making Jane Austen’s beloved story come to life. The 2005 version not only explores the novel’s themes of pride, social class, and commentary/comedy well, but also enhances the naturalistic feeling of Pride and Prejudice; Wright doesn’t shy away from muddy hems, the bustling house of the Bennet family, and the intimate interiors of ballrooms. With Dario Marianelli’s dreamy piano score and the painterly setting of several English counties, as well as the masterly performances of Kiera Knightly and Matthew Macfadyen, this classic adaptation is sure to capture the hearts of all viewers– no matter if you’re watching it for the first or hundredth time.
2. ATONEMENT (2007)
Shot by Seamus McGarvey, Atonement has gone down in period-piece history as one of the most beautiful films cinematographically. One could watch it on mute and still be captivated by the screen the whole time, for the illustration of memory, perception, subjectivity, and morality are perfectly enhanced by the motion of the camera and choice of color/lighting. Once again directed by Joe Wright and starring Kiera Knightly, Ian McEwan’s novel and characters are brought to life. Ironically, this story of moral bleakness and fragmentation delivers a lively cinematic experience, one that emotionally attaches itself to anyone who watches.
3. THE COUNT OF MONTE CRISTO (2002)
While vastly different as a film than book, Kevin Reynolds’ adaptation of The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas executes the adventure and intrigue of the original story. The expansive and methodical novel transforms into a clear revenge narrative on screen, with Jim Caviezel flawlessly portraying the complex Edmond Dantès. Betrayal, injustice, and redemption are illustrated through depth and shadow, with the cinematography relying on raw physicality rather than psychological abstraction. Unlike Atonement and Little Women, the cinematography relies less on inventive framing and more on traditional technique– however, the clarity in narrative combined with intriguing drama and adventure makes this film a great starting place in the realm of classic adaptations.
4. ANNE OF GREEN GABLES (1985)
If only one word described Anne of Green Gables, whether it be the novel or the 1985 film, it would be lush. Even though the gritty 2017 T.V. series usually gets the hype for best adaptation, this older movie captures the true experience of reading L.M. Montgomery’s coming-of-age tale, filled with humor, warmth, and loveable characters. Shot primarily in Prince Edward Island, the scenery of Canada’s open fields and dazzling lakes brings Green Gables to Life. Megan Follows plays the role of Anne to the core, embodying her imaginative, bold, and courageous character. It is clear this adaptation was made with reverence for the original tale, rather than revisionism.
5. LITTLE WOMEN (2019)
Like Kevin Sullivan’s vision for Anne of Green Gables, most classic novel adaptations are effective when they stick to the original body of work. However, Greta Gerwig’s Little Women (2019) is one exception when subtle modernization feels more truthful to the heart of the story. With a greater focus on feminism and female roles of the era, along with realistic sisterhood narratives, Gerwig’s creative execution feels timeless compared to previous adaptations. The cinematography and coloring is exceptional– the vividness of youth contrasted with a more realistic-colored present enhances the story and timeline of the four young women. The script and delivery, along with the constant movement of the camera were notably important to the director, conveying relatable dynamics throughout the movie. So next time you have your girlfriends over for a sleepover, consider watching this classic illustration of female friendships and their strength.